James Carafano: Coronavirus and regime change — will this plague topple nations great and small?

Get all the latest news on coronavirus and more delivered daily to your inbox.  Sign up here.

There will a world after the coronavirus pandemic. Many of the first-wave countries tsunamied by COVID-19 appear to be slowing the spread of the disease within their borders.

Yes, the world must still battle the virus for some time to come, but it’s worth pondering now: What will the world will look once the current onslaught is over? Will this plague topple nations great and small? 

We can’t know for sure, but we can start making some educated guesses.


For starters, don't bet on a linear relationship between disastrous times and the fall of regimes. After a series of bad harvests and a riot at the Bastille, the French king came tumbling down. On the other hand, Bin Laden thought he could topple America with one hammer-blow on Sept. 11, 2001 — and he’s the one who wound up going down.  

In “The Rise and Fall of Civilizations,” Jared Diamond warns against banking on singular, linear relationships to explain the rise and fall of regimes.  France, after all, was a rich and powerful nation, yet the king still lost his head. On the other hand, early modern England got smacked with the plague, a civil war, a revolution, a series of foreign wars and a mini-Ice Age — and still emerged as one of history’s most powerful empires.  

So all we can do is guess about how regimes will weather the coronavirus storm. And in making that assessment, we must also consider not only their response to the virus, but also economic decisions, political turmoil, natural disasters (hurricane season is coming) and external factors that weigh mightily on their stability.

Remember, even if the discontented want to foment protest, extremism and political change, the pandemic creates a unique set of challenges for them. With the world social distancing, it’s harder to get organized; mass protests, for example, are harder to pull off. Moreover, in responding to the pandemic, regimes may institute even more rigorous travel restrictions, security measures and monitoring policies — all of which inhibit opposition, both clandestine and overt. 

In times of social distancing, the Internet can be a blessing. But it can also be a problem. For example, experts already worry about more radicalization by Islamist and other fringe political factions, because those most vulnerable to their hateful propaganda have more time at home to absorb their extremist dribble. Arguably, the most vulnerable regimes might be the ones that are the most networked.

Parliamentary democracies, which are most sensitive to rapid shifts in political attitude, might be the most vulnerable. So far, however, there is little evidence of that. Governments in hard hit places like Taiwan and South Korea appear more popular. Countries like the U.K. and Germany have little to fear, as they lack a viable political opposition that people would trust to govern. (Not to mention the daunting challenge of figuring out how to hold credible mass elections in the middle of a pandemic.)

Some have argued that authoritarian regimes are better at dealing with COVID-19, but there is no credible evidence supporting that. For the most part, we have seen them pursue appalling public health policies, imposed by brute force alone. Meanwhile, democracies such as South Korea have demonstrated that it doesn't take a dictatorship to get on top of a crisis.

Will the lies, inefficiencies and suffering propagated by the coronavirus response of authoritarian regimes bring their downfall? That looks unlikely in places like China, Russia, North Korea and Iran. These are world-class oppressive regimes that have weathered some pretty tough times. 

What we might expect, however, is that, in the short term, these global bad boys might be a little more risk averse, realizing they have to prioritize domestic stability over foreign adventurism. Iran, for example, has had to dedicate 20 percent of its government funding to pandemic response. That leaves less money for exporting misery to its neighbors.

Where we are most likely to see turmoil is in places where the government is already a basket case. Venezuela and Syria are prime examples. These governments can't even keep the lights on, let alone mount a public health response to an epidemic. On the other hand, where shaky regimes can rely on powerful external sponsors —vlike the Russians and Cubans in the case of Venezuelav—vthe odds against the people kicking out their oppressors remain daunting.

Many argue COVID-19 will change the world forever. Perhaps. But as of now, that remains an open question. There’s also a good chance we’ll see far more continuity than change in world affairs, once COVID-19 has run its course, economies come back online, and we distance ourselves from social distancing.    


TAGS: James Carafano Coronavirus and regime change will this plague topple nations great and small?

31 Mar 2020 17:08   |    163

Source: www.foxnews.com

Allah disdains not to use the similitude of things, even of a gnat as well as anything above it. Those who believe know that it is truth from their Lord; but those who reject Faith say: "What means Allah by this similitude?" By it He causes many to stray, and many He leads into the right path; but He causes not to stray, except those who forsake (the path),- (The Cow   26 )


Ocasio-Cortez backs Engel’s challenger in primary
100-year-old coronavirus survivors share their longevity secrets
More than $20G raised to help Minneapolis woman who wept over riots in viral interview
GOP convention site in limbo: Here’s where party could go
Gutfeld on the murder of Mr. Dorn
As George Floyd protests continue, Amazon, Google pledge millions to racial justice organizations
Ex-CIA spy Valerie Plame loses House bid in New Mexico Dem primary
NBA to approve 22-team return with Orlando playing host: reports
Florida sheriff speaks out on taking a knee with demonstrators
Jimmy Failla: George Floyd unrest -- Biden, Democrats want to score political points, skirt honesty
Arthur Herman: Riots, looting and America burning — the end of the progressive dream
Rep. Andy Biggs: End riots, restore freedom – too many aiding bad behavior
Biden and Trump all tied up in Texas: poll
Tom Homan: Message to all the good cops out there – Americans stand with you
Conservative activist turns tables on Dems over claims of voter suppression
Congressional Black Caucus chair rejects call to defund police, but pushes for June vote on reforms
Trump claims he’s done more for black Americans than any president other than Lincoln
Ex-Baltimore mayor, once convicted of embezzlement, now favorite to fill seat of mayor convicted of fraud
RNC says convention ‘will be held in another city’ after Trump abandons Charlotte, search underway
Biden has edge over Trump on handling race relations: poll

Email subscription:

Related Opinion News