Senate vote allowing FBI to snoop on Internet browsing gets slammed but security experts push back

Legislation that would let the FBI access American’s browsing and search histories is getting attacked but some experts see it differently.

Earlier this month, the Senate passed a reauthorization of the Patriot Act with language allowing the FBI to see your browser data without a warrant. But before the final passage, an amendment, which would have limited access to browser and search histories, was defeated.

In response there have been a swath of headlines warning of the danger of warrantless surveillance.


Just this week, more than 50 groups wrote a letter to lawmakers in the House urging them to block the bill, including the ACLU, NAACP, Muslim Justice League, and Progress America.

“Internet search and browsing history is extremely revealing in nature and the Fourth Amendment requires a warrant to obtain this information,” the letter said.

It also drew fire from Libertarian groups, such as Being Libertarian, which said in a Facebook post that the senators “sold out your freedoms. They all voted for federal agencies to have access to your internet history without obtaining a warrant.”

But fact-checking has revealed that this legislation isn’t new and simply maintains the status quo.

“This authority is nothing new,” Politifact said. “It’s been allowed for 20 years in foreign intelligence investigations, and is also allowed in basic criminal investigations -- all without a warrant.

“The vote referenced here applied only to Americans ‘relevant’ to counterterrorism and counterintelligence investigation. Though a warrant isn’t needed, investigators still must get a court to sign off on the internet data access," Politifact said, alluding to Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISC).

The experts that contacted agreed about the overreaction.

“It’s not new. Law enforcement has been able to get that data without a warrant for at least since the 1980s. National security investigations got similar authority no later than 2001 (USA PATRIOT),” Stewart Baker, former general counsel of the National Security Agency, told in an email.


“This is a misrepresentation,” Baker added. “It is the people trying to jam yet another amendment into the Senate and original FISA bills who are trying to change the law,” he said, referring to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA).

James Lewis, senior vice president and director of the Technology Policy Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, told that “It's a long-standing practice (Section 215 of the Patriot Act)."

He added that it's the reactions to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISC) that are too extreme: “Concerns about the FISC are misplaced if not hysterical."


TAGS: Senate vote allowing FBI to snoop on Internet browsing gets slammed but security experts push back

23 May 2020 06:42   |    127


Allah disdains not to use the similitude of things, even of a gnat as well as anything above it. Those who believe know that it is truth from their Lord; but those who reject Faith say: "What means Allah by this similitude?" By it He causes many to stray, and many He leads into the right path; but He causes not to stray, except those who forsake (the path),- (The Cow   26 )


Andrew McCarthy: Laws against rioting and terrorism must be enforced against Antifa and other violent radicals
FBI General Counsel Dana Boente to retire from bureau, Wray says
Jason Chaffetz: Justice for George Floyd – zero tolerance for rogue cops and lawlessness
Paul Batura: America is a spacefaring nation again, as historic launch gives us a welcome dose of good news
SpaceX makes history, launches NASA astronauts into space from US soil for the first time since 2011
Helen Raleigh: Welcome Hong Kong political refugees – 3 reasons US should act now
Bruce Mehlman: Economic recovery from coronavirus demands more available, affordable and accessible broadband
Key West high school follows coronavirus social distancing measures with Jet Ski graduation
Donna Brazile: In age of coronavirus, my commencement address to Class of 2020 – advice for tough times
David Limbaugh: Kayleigh McEnany gets vitriol hurled at her daily by liberal media -- and it proves this
Gordon G. Chang: Trump is right to ditch 5 decades of failed US-China engagement policy
Minnesota requests more help as riots continue there -- and across US
5 ways to block or hide your number when making calls
Supreme Court rejects challenge to limits on church services; Roberts sides with liberals
Homeless Jacksonville student to graduate as high school valedictorian, attend college
Rudy Giuliani calls for Minneapolis mayor to resign in wake of George Floyd protests
Cruz calls for criminal investigation into Twitter for violating US sanctions on Iran
Deroy Murdock: Rioters do injustice to George Floyd, tortured and killed in a case of police brutality
Dinosaur-killing asteroid created massive magma chamber that lasted millions of years, study shows
Bob Casey, Dem senator from Pennsylvania, says antibody test shows he had coronavirus

Email subscription:

Related Tech News